Puttanesca Chiefs 2025 Season Review


Analysis by Alex

At a glance

Top 5 Scorers

PlayerGamesAverageRank
Max Holmes23100.923
Gryan Miers2193.844
Clayton Oliver2289.761
Nick Blakey238586
Tom De Koning2284.787

Season Summary

Do we consider the year a failure given this team played finals in 2024? Or was that a false dawn as many of the competition for that 6th place finish fell over each other in the run home? The parity of the league means that the 8 teams above them were all pushing for finals, while Mark and his Chiefs are rebuilding, so 9th was probably a fair outcome as opposed to expecting another finals run.

This team scored 300 points more (at an average of a whopping 14ppg) than in 2024, so while it is incremental, improvement is still improvement. As there are many young players on this list, there is a need for patience for the natural development to continue. 

9th place for the second time in 3 years is not ideal, but 3 flags in the first 10 years buys a coach a lot of grace with the powers that be. While the 2026 outlook is probably not finals again, seeing growth from within the 20 keepers (plus the 2 first round picks up their sleeve for this season) would still be a positive outcome.

Season Grade: C-


All-Australians

2: Max Holmes, Gryan Miers

DangerGawn Votes

RankPlayerVotes
6Max Holmes16
28Tom De Koning7
42Kade Chandler5
51Ed Langdon4
52Clayton Oliver4
71Gryan Miers3
74Miles Bergman3
102Nick Blakey2
109Josh Battle1
111Xavier Duursma1
122Colby McKercher1

Pre-Season Draft

PickPlayerGPAvg
5Sam Lalor1059.1
15Taj Hotton350.33
25Braeden Campbell1058.5
35Kai Lohmann550.4
36Josh Battle1971.11
45Toby Conway00
49Jacob van Rooyen00
65Ben Ainsworth1361.23
75Charlie Comben00
95Max King00
105Brayden Maynard1371.69
115Ben Camporeale00
125Corey Wagner1467
135Mark Keane116
145Kade Chandler1969.68
155Lucca Grego00
165Phoenix Gothard00
175Tom Barrass00
185Sam Berry969.89
195Brodie Smith246.5

Most Inspired Selection

Pick 36 – Josh Battle

Josh Battle in the 4th round was the highlight outside of these rookies. A defender who made the All Australian team (robbing Josh Worrell of the berth in the process, but that’s a gripe for another day) is never a bad player to have, and with an average of 70 and room to go bigger again in 2026, a handy player for more than the one year for the Chiefs.

Honourable mention to Kade Chandler. Picked in the 15th round also with an average of 70, a handy player to pick up that late. As a forward a score worth fielding most weeks, but probably at his ceiling for what he could bring to a fantasy team.


Trades

13 March 2025RoughnecksRowan Marshall
ChiefsRoughnecks 2026 Round 1 pick

Roughnecks 2026 Round 3 pick

Oliver Dempsey

Only one trade to dissect, and a very clear strategy to it. Rowan Marshall is an elite ruck, which comes with elite value on the trade block. Mark was able to bring in the reigning rising star winner (with thanks to the match review panel in suspending his competition), as well as a first and third round pick to strengthen another draft hand. With TDK already on the Chiefs list, the ruck line is still secure for many years to come.

List at end of 2025 season

PlayerAgeGPAVGRank
Max Holmes2323100.923
Gryan Miers262193.844
Clayton Oliver282289.761
Nick Blakey25238586
Tom De Koning262284.787
Sam Docherty311584.488
Xavier Duursma252278.8121
James Rowbottom252378.7122
Colby McKercher202378.5125
Miles Bergman231978.2129
Ollie Hollands212376.2138
Jack Ginnivan222275.3144
Ed Langdon292374.2153
Ollie Dempsey222372.7165
Josh Battle272370.3179
Kade Chandler252368.7190
Ryan Angwin22968.3193
Brayden Maynard291866.4209
Mark O’Connor282264.5227
Rhys Stanley341864.4229
Corey Wagner281764.2231
Bodhi Uwland222363.1246
Cam Mackenzie211262.5254
Sam Berry231762.4258
Shannon Neale232261.3274
Brody Mihocek322058.7301
Ben Ainsworth272258.6304
Logan Morris202257.7321
Braeden Campbell232356.6337
Sam Lalor191154.1372
Anthony Caminiti212353.8376
Taj Hotton19750.9421
Nick Watson202249.9431
Kai Lohmann221446.3474
Jhye Clark21738.3551
Jed Walter201637.9555
Archer Reid201435.7571
Paddy Dow25774
Tanner Bruhn23788
Toby Conway22791

Player to watch in 2026

Colby McKercher

Entering year 3, it’s time for the former pick #2 (both in the AFL and more importantly, Dangergawn) to show us what he’s made of. A couple of years, a couple of roles, as North Melbourne are prone to do, and so we haven’t seen Colby settle into his work just yet. The time is now for that to change. An average of 82 in his rookie year helped him burst onto the scene as an elite prospect, however a second year regression to 78 gave Mark a pause as to how his development would continue to trend. There are no more excuses for the Roos. You drafted him, you’ve worked through his development, now is the time to find his role, and give Mark 10 years of bliss.