2023 Season Review: Solomon’s Soldiers


AT A GLANCE

Wins

19

Losses

2

1st on the ladder

Season Summary

Not much to say here. They’re the best. The question is how long can they stay the best.

The Mills and Gresham trade is instructive here. The Soldiers are encountering the problem of having more good players than they can keep, and have landed on a formula of trading out keeper level players for great draft selections. Will they be able to keep who they select at pick 4? They will if they’re Sheezel like, obviously. But what if they’re Josh Sinn like. Or Will Phillips. Or even someone like Horne-Francis. Can this team justify a keeper spot on that? Or will they simply return to the trade table, and try again the following year.

This isn’t an old team. But it isn’t a young one anymore either. Time has finally caught up with the Chiefs. It remains to be seen when it will catch up with the Defenestrators. The question is will the Soldiers put their chips in and maximise their chances of going 3 in a row. Or will they try to cop a short term stepback to try and keep the gravy train rolling? The Mills trade is an indication toward the latter. It is hard to argue pick 4 helps them more than Mills does when it comes to a flag in 2024. But the Soldiers are clearly banking on the idea they can do without Mills. They won’t notice. It won’t slow them down. They’re so far in front they can afford to trade away premium players to try and get the pillar of the next dynasty before this one is over. If it works out for them, it’s masterful. But those others with designs on winning the flag should take heart at the Mills trade. Success for the rest of us is just that little, little bit closer thanks to it.

top five  Players

Marcus Bontempelli

23 games
117 average
Ranked 2nd for season

Christian Petracca

23 games
106 average
Ranked 15th for season

Sam Docherty

20 games
104.5 average
Ranked 18th for season

James Sicily

19 games
104.5 average
Ranked 19th for season

Josh Dunkley

21 games
104.4 average
Ranked 20th for season

ALL-AUSTRALIANS


Sam Docherty

James Sicily

Marcus Bontempelli

Christian Petracca

Josh Dunkley

Brad Crouch

2023 PRE-SEASON DRAFT

RoundPickPlayerGames PlayedAverage
213Cameron (GEE)1886.11
330Weddle (Haw)458.25
542T. Greene (GWS)1986.95
543Zorko (BL)1483.21
544Lycett (PA)137
545Milera (AD)771.71
546Constable (GC)181
549Dangerfield (GEE)1175.64
550Setterfield (ESS)785
880D. Tucker (NTH)654.5
1094S. May (Mel)770.86
10100Cotchin (RICH)568
12120Goldstein (NTH)965.33
13130J. Fletcher (BL)156
14140Fox (SYD)567.6
15150G. Clark (WC)154
16160T. Walker (ADL)1182.36
17170C. Wagner (FRE)377.67
18180McComb (WB)00
19190Menegola (GEE)00
20200C. Blakely (GC)00

Most Inspired Selection

Toby Greene
Pick 42

Focused predominately on established contributors and that approach mostly paid dividends here. Most of their selections featured for the Soldiers at some point during the season. Cameron, Greene, Zorko and Walker formed half the Soldiers forward line. That’s great work in anyone’s language. Some of these guys are likely to be kept in the face of the forward dearth, and the one least likely to be kept won the Franklin Medal.

Trades

Volume slightly down on the Soldiers usually prolific standards.

One imagines they’re disappointed in the deal with Pukekos for Yeo. The logic is sound. What use is pick 10 to a team gunning for the flag. The year before they traded what turned out to be pick 10 for James Sicily, and I imagine that move keeps coach Bridge warm at night. The logic is the same here, but the result hasn’t been as productive. Now we wait to see if they keep Yeo…

Sending out De Goey for Young is a win. De Goey was better in 2023, but Young is, well, younger, and his move into the Fremantle midfield toward season’s end yielded some very impressive results.

Sending out a third round pick for surprising 2023 star Mason Wood is very tidy work. Even if they don’t keep Wood, they won the flag, and Wood averaged 96 across the two finals he played for the Soldiers.

DateTeamPlayerTeamPlayer
September 30, 2023MaherShalalHashBaz Round 1 pick (pick 4)

MaherShalalHashBaz Round 7 pick (pick 64)
Callum Mills

Jade Gresham

Solomon’s Soldiers Round 5 pick (pick 50)

Threat Level Midnight Round 10 pick (pick 93)
August 4, 2023Mason Wood

Threat Level Midnight Round 10 pick
Solomon’s Soldiers Round 3 pick
April 11, 2023Jordan De GoeyHayden Young
March 11, 2023Solomon’s Soldiers Round 1 Pick

Solomon’s Soldiers Round 6 Pick
Elliot Yeo

Te Puke Pukekos

Round 5 Pick

Te Puke Pukekos Round 15

LIST AT END OF 2023 SEASON

PlayerGamesAveragePlayer Rank
Marcus Bontempelli
Midfielder
231172
Christian Petracca
Midfielder
2310615
Sam Docherty
Defender / Midfielder
20104.518
James Sicily
Defender
19104.519
Josh Dunkley
Midfielder / Forward
21104.420
Brad Crouch
Midfielder
23103.321
Toby Nankervis
Ruck
15102.323
Jack Viney
Midfielder
2210027
Lachie Neale
Midfielder
239737
Dan Houston
Defender
2392.749
Will Setterfield
Midfielder
109255
Mason Wood
Midfielder
2391.658
Dustin Martin
Midfielder / Forward
209062
Caleb Daniel
Defender / Forward
2389.964
Hugh McCluggage
Midfielder
2289.369
Hayden Young
Defender
2289.271
Toby GreeneForward2188.572
James Worpel
Midfielder
2386.384
Dayne Zorko
Forward / Midfielder
1784.891
Callum Mills
Midfielder
1984.194
Charlie Constable
Defender / Midfielder
28496
Jeremy Cameron
Forward
208399
Taylor Walker
Forward
2280.4115
Daniel Rioli
Defender
2380.3116
Patrick Dangerfield
Midfielder
1879.9120
Peter Ladhams
Ruck
976.2143
Jade Gresham
Midfielder / Forward
2273.6172
Wayne Milera
Forward / Defender
2271.4197
Elliot Yeo
Defender
1070.1210
Keidean Coleman
Defender
2069.6218
Steven May
Defender
2169.5220
Jayden Laverde
Defender
1967.4233
Tom Hickey
Ruck
1166.7243
Hayden McLean
Forward
2165.6254
Scott Lycett
Ruck
1263.2271
Henry Hustwaite
Midfielder
262.5286
Darcy Tucker
Midfielder / Forward
1860.8307
Mason Cox
Ruck / Forward
1659.4327
Josh Goater
Defender / Midfielder
1054.5393
James Borlase
Defender
439563

Player To Watch in 2024

James Worpel

This one is hard to answer. I’m more interested in who they keep and who they cut.

I’m going to go with James Worpel as I’m pretty sure he’ll be kept, and he’s one of the few they could keep who could pose question marks. Was great last season and justified the decision to keep him heading into 2023. Is he a long term mainstay in the Hawthorn midfield?

season

Grade: a